Oct 26, 2004 would strict constructionism have freed dred scott. If one can justify actions as constitutional to meet their own needs, then the constitution might as well not exist. It is also known as liberal constructionism this is because. Loose construction is it is the basis for the forming of political parties under president adams. Also referred to as strict interpretation or original intent, because a person who follows the doctrine of strict construction of the constitution tries to ascertain the intent of the framers at the time the document was written by considering what the language they used meant at.
Twentyseven of these, having been ratified by the requisite number of states 38, since 1959, are part of the constitution. The myth of strict constructionism and conservative judicial restraint conservative republicans and tea party activists have been arguing vehemently that the u. This theory contrasts with a loose construction of laws, which allows broader discretion by judges to determine intent in legal language. Strict constructionalism is a judicial philosophy that adheres to the constitution as written, rather than interpreting it to keep up with the times. Strict constructionists believe that interpreting new rights into the constitution is a dangerous exercise because there is nothing to guide the development of new rights other than a judges individual conscience. Learn strict constructionist approach with free interactive flashcards.
Would strict constructionism have freed dred scott. Use our quizzes and accompanying worksheets before you. Its most commonly discussed in the context of the u. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. Rather, he viewed it as a lesser form of textualism and argued that the words should. The philosophical problems with strict construction. This book is a must read for anyone interested in u. A strict constructionist would interpret the constitution. Strict constructionists are judges who interpret legal texts only as they are written, ignoring context and circumstances. They push it aside as a historical curiosity, in much the same way that more modernist justices sometimes push the second amendment aside.
A strict constructionist judge would, by definition, take article v and the thirteenth amendment into account because a strict constructionist judge would rule on the current state of the constitution. List of amendments to the united states constitution wikipedia. Apr 20, 2018 supreme court justices who belong to the strict constructionist school of interpretation essentially say that the ninth amendment is too vague to have any binding authority. A close or narrow reading and interpretation of a statute or written document. Marshall successfully asserted federalist dominance in the supreme court and protected commerce by using strict constructionism and broad constructionism, respectively. Abiding by the laws and articles of the constitution to a precise point. They result in building social capital, trust and shared values, which politically, help hold society together. The latter wants the national governmental powers be limited only according to the constitution while the latter believe to what power is used depending only to whats needed.
Strict constructionthis phrase purports to describe a method of constitutional interpretation. To be fair, before concluding that strict constructionism is all about political outcomes, not the constitution, the article quotes professor akhil amar, who unsurprisingly provides a more helpful assessment of strict constructionism. Nov 04, 2012 in establishing republican dominance in government, jefferson determined to use strict constructionism. By roger roots if you tune into any national political debate these days, you are likely to be subjected to a tiresome dialogue regarding the types of judges that should be nominated and approved to sit on the federal bench.
Strict constructionism refers to a particular way of interpreting the constitution and the laws of the united states. In establishing republican dominance in government, jefferson determined to use strict constructionism. Taken from my notes and previous apush unit 2 quizlets from the seniors apush unit 2 study guide by claremdurand includes 89 questions covering vocabulary, terms and more. Judgesin this viewshould avoid drawing inferences from a statute or constitution and focus only on the text itself.
The purchase order form provides customer information, shipping address, salesperson, payment type, and the price and quantities of items ordered. Wisconsin judge rules against scott walker in special. Loose and strict constructionism the republicans jefferson and madison, and the federalists, mainly hamilton, hated each other. The decadeslong battle for federal supremacy was inti. Furthermore, it does not mention turning the territory into states. The texts position is that the enormous increase in court cases and the degree of judicial activism by federal courts are most directly related to an increase in contending interests. For example, when jefferson was president, his two basic political doctrines were strict affiliation to the letter of the constitution and severe economy in spending public money. The myth of strict constructionism and conservative judicial. Strict constructionisim, or original intent, is a theory limiting interpretation of legal and constitutional language to the literal meaning of this language at the time of passage. Strict malleable is the only legitimate way of interpreting the constitution, as it is an otherwise worthless document. I am not a strict constructionist, and no one ought to be though better that, i suppose, than a nontextualist.
This book is licensed under a creative commons byncsa 3. In the idea of a living constitution lies an inherent lack of regard for it. Social constructionism strengths and weaknesses free essays. Thomas jefferson a prominent statesman, thomas jefferson became george washingtons first secretary of state. The division 2 might set a record for most depictions of book reading in a bigbudget game. In its strict sense, strict construction requires a judge to apply the text as it is written and no. A strict constructionist follow laws in a specific manner. The contest between judicial activism and strict constructionism is one of the most important issues in constitutional theories and practices. Two views about interpreting the constitution study the following arguments for the strict and loose constructionist viewpoints of constitutional law. A strict constructionist would interpret the constitution exactly as it was written in the text. Classically, a strict construction is one that narrowly construes congresss power under article i, section 8.
For more information on the source of this book, or why it is. If you tell somebody something, youve forever robbed them of the opportunity to discover it for themselves. The purpose of the enumerate powers is to limit the federal government to specific functions. Constitution, to apply the text of the law, exactly as written, in making judgements and rulings. An intimate history of the black death, the most devastating plague of all time. On the campaign trail in 2000, for example, president george w. Its sort of meaningless because sometimes text is unclear. Loose constructivism were supported by federalists while strict constructivists are supported by democraticrepublican. Strict constructionism vs broad constructionism essay 715 words. In this lesson, you will be introduced to the concept of strict constructionism through definitions. Strict constructionism refers to the practice of applying a narrow, or strict, interpretation of the u. Mar 23, 2020 strict constructionalism is a judicial philosophy that adheres to the constitution as written, rather than interpreting it to keep up with the times. For a document that has been the supreme law of the land in the u. Strict constructionism applies a strict interpretation of the u.
Broad constructionism vs strict constructionism essay. Strict constructionism vs broad constructionism essay sample. Kelly meticulously documents the black deaths march through the world, from its first appearance in china to its final days, after it wiped out to 1 2 of europes population. Where the document is unclear, strict constructionalism attempts to ascertain the framers intent through letters and other documents from the time of the constitutions creation. Congress should be allowed to exercise many implied powers so that. Choose from 52 different sets of strict constructionist approach flashcards on quizlet. When practicing strict constructionism, justices will take an issue and look for the original intent of the founding fathers in the constitution. Law is vague, and even the text as is will change over time. Thirtythree amendments to the united states constitution have been proposed by the united states congress and sent to the states for ratification since the constitution was put into operation on march 4, 1789. In the constitution, it does not mention acquiring foreign territories. Those whom best 1989 calls strict constructionists have attempted to chart the types of argument and appeal used by social problems claimsmakers without making reality claims of their own ibarra and kitsuse, 1993. Strict constructionist means you just look at the text, not any other source. Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation. Once the court has a clear meaning of the text, no further investigation is required.
Strict constructionism is the judicial philosophy whereby the constitution is interpreted in a literal or strict manner. Justice antonin scalia, appointed by ronald reagan to the supreme court in 1984, embodies the modern strict constructionist. Untitled flashcards at south texas high school for health. In his seminal book on interpreting legal texts, a matter of interpretation, justice scalia said in no uncertain terms. Loose construction was for more power of the national government. During jeffersons presidency, the united states purchased land west of the mississippi from napoleon, known as the louisiana purchase. Do you side more with the strict or the loose constructionists. For words and phrases are not unchanging things, but rather imperfect vessels themselves. September 9, 2016 by kevin hall in political terms, a strict constructionist believes that the laws spelled out in the constitution of the united states are not malleable. In fact, i found what became one of my favorite booksa conflict of visions by thomas sowellon this reading list. Also referred to as strict interpretation or original intent, because a person who follows the doctrine of strict construction of the constitution tries to ascertain the intent of the framers at the time the document was written by considering what. Confirm what you know about the strict constructionist approach by responding to this quiz. What would a strict constructionist and a judicial.
Along with james madison, jefferson took up the cause of strict constructionists and the republican party, advocating limited. Strict constructionist is the dumb version of originalism. On the back of this paper, draw a tchart that summarizes the main points for each position. This is activists and strict constructionists, section 2. Strict constructionism vs broad constructionism essay example for free newyorkessays database with more than 65000 college essays for studying. I think your confused about the ninth and 10th amendments. In this brief book, justice antonin scalia summarizes key aspects of his core judicial philosophy, such as textualism and originalism. The american legal system and the courts learn with flashcards, games, and more for free. Theory of strict construction constitution society. Jefferson found it necessary to use broad constructionism in his decision to purchase the louisiana territory, but stuck to strict constructionism in shaping the federal government. Strict constructionism and loose constructionism in restoration history james b. Adams purchase order books provide a professional 2 part carbonless invoice give customers the perforated white top copy, keep the canary copy for your records.
Strict constructionist definition is one who favors giving a narrow conservative construction of a given document or instrument. Judges are often called upon to make a construction, or interpretation, of an unclear term in cases that involve a dispute over the terms legal significance. Strict construction requires a judge to apply the text only as it is written. Those using it, however, often are not referring to the same interpretive method. But in his book on interpreting legal texts, a matter of interpretation, justice scalia himself said in. Strengths and weaknesses of the social capital approach. Loose constructionism vs strict constructionism casual. Nov 16, 2010 your presentation on strict constructionism of this document saved your law professor having to prep a lecture. Strict constructionism describes a legal theory that embraces a narrow reading of legal texts. Strict constructionism refers to a particular legal philosophy of judicial interpretation that limits or restricts judicial interpretation.
Upon his inauguration in 1801, president thomas jefferson promulgated his belief in a limited government. Strict constructionism is a legal theory that embraces a very narrow reading of statutes and laws, and essentially limits readers to what is written on the four corners of a given page without considering context or circumstances. According to strict constructionism, analysts are not allowed to come to conclusions about the relative merits of a given claim best, 1993. What is the difference between loose constructionism and strict constructionism when it comes to interpreting the u. In the united states the phrase is also commonly used more loosely as a generic term for conservatism among the judiciary.
Once the court has a clear meaning of the text, no. Hey all, doing some work on the supreme court and i need some help. The perennial source of confusion regarding constitutional interpretation, one that even the founders suffered from, arose from the conflict between requiring a supermajority to amend the constitution, but only a majority to interpret it. Feb 17, 2015 despite your claims, the issues we see today in modern society are no different than that of the framers, just the scale is different. Strict constructionism vs broad constructionism essay. Theory of strict construction jon roland, 19990204. Strict constructionism and loose constructionism in restorati published by pepperdine digital commons, 1999.
Jefferson was a strict constructionist, meaning he followed the constitution word by word. William marbury had been one of the midnight judges appointed by john adams in his last hours as president. Get an answer for what would a strict constructionist and a judicial interpretivist disagree on. Bush promised to appoint strict constructionists in the mold of justices rhenquist, scalia, and thomas, though thomas considers himself an originalist, and scalia leans more toward textualism on statutory questions, rather than true strict constructionism. Putnams civil society is the idea that positive outcomes in government are a product of civic community, for example, networks of trust such as, soccer club or choral society p. The republicans jefferson and madison, and the federalists, mainly hamilton, hated each other. Understanding the ninth amendments effect and history. In the same period, the re publicans and southern demo crats have, in effect, more near ly espoused the old jefferson ian strict constructionism as, for instance, when many of both. When the case was decided in 1857, the constitution.
President jefferson, perhaps the largest proponent of strict constructionism of his time, did, in some cases, make executive decisions during his terms that would be considered those of a strict constructionist. I am not a strict constructionist, and no one ought to be. Situating constructionism by seymour papert and idit harel the following essay is the first chapter in seymour papert and idit harels book constructionism ablex publishing corporation, 1991. Strict constructionism and loose constructionism in. Wade was actually a model of strict constructionism.
Constitution, denying ratifications and insisting that congress should only exercise expressed powers. Scalia did not consider himself a strict constuctionist. Do strict constructionists wish to bring back slavery. The constitution caused jefferson problems deciding what to do. Lack ing any notion of the purposes of the creation of the republic, we lack any criteria for determining what are appropriate and inappropriate powers to be exercised by the federal government or upheld by the federal courts. The term strict constructionism refers to a philosophy of law that would restrict judicial interpretation of the law, as well as of the u. Originalism vs strict constructionist 11 justice blair. Strict constructionism definition, examples, cases. Upon his inauguration in 1801, president thomas jefferson promulgated his. It is easy enough to formulate simple catchy versions of the idea of constructionism.
Constitution, and is primarily an american legal concept. In other words, under strict constructionist principles, judges would not be allowed to consider the intent of the law, but be held to enforcing the actual wording. Political, social, and economic change after the american. What are the positives and negatives of loose constructionism. Ive posted a few times now about the supreme court, and at one point i noted that i had labeled myself a strict constructionist.
I assume you are referring to judicial philosophy i would say that i am a strict constructionist, but that does not imply that i am necessarily an originalist. Congress should be allowed to exercise very few implied powers so that government will remain small. In the united states the phrase is also commonly used more loosely as a generic term for conservativism among the judiciary strict sense of the term. In the united states, strict constructionism refers to a particular legal philosophy of judicial interpretation that limits or restricts judicial interpretation. Jan 27, 2008 it is then that the arcane terms of constitutional theory will make their way into the candidates speeches and become topics of discussion on political talk shows strict constructionism, originalism in several versions, textualism, pragmatism, the living constitution, etc. Its a simple thing, and not that important but im looking at judicial philosophies and ive got the basis. But some use strict construction to mean interpretations that limit the situations to which a constitutional. Textualism should not be confused with socalled strict constructionism, which is a degraded form of textualism that brings the whole philosophy into disrepute.
The american revolution instigated much change within the newly independent nation, particularly political and social, and to a lesser extent, economically. This passage is from justice scalias essay in the book, a matter of interpretation. If your reading of these amendments is accurate then americans have a right to a job. What does a strict constructionist believe see answers 2 ask for details. Thomas jefferson had the characteristics and beliefs of strict constructionists, but he also needed the help of broad constructionism. Mar 23, 2020 its a brilliant book and i highly recommend. Jan 01, 1997 reading a matter of interpretation was an effort to try and fill in some of the gaps of i heard about a matter of interpretation by looking over the federalist societys conservative and libertarian prelaw reading list.
1310 850 1020 1318 154 75 407 1429 975 6 152 445 742 1154 1235 326 1316 576 362 1308 786 746 758 1465 1236 426 835 1055 461 271 363 255 1015 766 1437 847 122 867 1028